You only have to mention something and ads appear on Facebook – is our phone really listening?

Phone callbackI call you at the time you choose
← Back to the blog
Blog

You only have to mention something and ads appear on Facebook – is our phone really listening?

Author: Lakatos Szilárd | Published:

I swear I hadn't even searched for the word „dog", let alone „preparing to own a dog", „dog training", „best dog food", when it turned out that – surprise! – we were getting a dog. I hadn't ordered anything online and certainly hadn't watched videos on YouTube. We'd only exchanged a few words about it in chat; most of the communication happened in person, and lo and behold:

when the dog arrived and we agreed to leave it alone for a while to settle in, I checked my Facebook, and it was full of dog-school ads.

Instagram greeted me with the same, of course. And these weren't just any ads: videos in which anonymous „experts" explained in detail how to ruin (read: how I'll ruin) the dog's socialisation, how I'd make every possible mistake and end up returning a nervous, traumatised animal to the shelter. Unless I subscribed to their crash course, thanks to which ten minutes of training a day would turn the dog into a happy little lamb – but they'd really only reveal more after I'd given my bank account number.

It's no surprise that a whole industry is built around owning and training dogs, which now – even with the help of AI – churns out content of dubious credibility. Every „dog school" claims the same thing – that only they hold the key, and we shouldn't listen to trainers using traditional methods – and every such video is made from the same mould. It's the same with every other topic, I'm used to it: if I get interested in watches, my feed fills up with related ads, and the same goes for interior design, dieting, cycling, photography. Targeted ads have long been part of our lives. But now, for the first time, what I'd only heard legends about happened: I talk to someone about something, an important life event follows, and then my phone is flooded with related ads. Is the phone really listening? How? I certainly never gave permission for that! Or did I? Who benefits?!

The answer: yes and no. Disheartening – not even a real answer – so let's get into the details. The urban legends about eavesdropping devices are false, but the reality is both scarier and sadder.

The most important thing – and truly every expert says this, not just representatives of social platforms and their stakeholders – is that

no, the phone uses neither the microphone nor the camera

to listen in on our private conversations and target ads based on them. Not because Meta, Google and the other giants that live mainly on ad revenue are morally and ethically spotless and feel this would cross a certain line, but because it's technically unfeasible.

Imagine if your phone's microphone ran all day, secretly streaming audio to a server at full tilt. Speech isn't much data, but streamed continuously it would mean many, many gigabytes of uploads a month; even if the big companies quietly agreed with the carriers not to show it on users' phones (and bills), it would still push their servers to the limit. Not to mention your phone's battery.

It's also impossible for the phone to listen only for important sentences and words – how would it know which ones they are? And all the computing power and AI assistance in the world couldn't interpret and weigh everything we say in every language.

So what's happening?

Simple: social media apps don't listen in on users, because there's a far more effective and clever method. They track them. And we're not just talking about location data, but about user habits – that is, everything. Honestly: have you ever read even part of the terms and privacy policy before accepting? If not, no one blames you: these endlessly long, dry texts are long and dry precisely so you won't want to know – and won't care later – what you give companies in exchange for using their apps like Facebook, Gmail, Instagram and TikTok „for free" (read: in exchange for your data).

Just a few examples. Facebook and Instagram watch, for instance:

  • which post you read,
  • which image you keep on screen and for how long,
  • after how long and where you swipe,
  • which pages you're an enthusiastic fan of,
  • who you keep in touch with and how closely,
  • which external websites you browse, where you sign in with your Facebook account,
  • what you spend on and how much (read: how wealthy you are),
  • who you're physically near, even under the same roof; if GPS data shows you're often close to each other, the app assumes you also talk.

This data, constantly collected from billions of users – to use a slightly sensationalist term:

BIG DATA

(if you're interested and want to read more, click here)

– is much, much easier to analyse than mere audio recordings. The result of the analysis – which naturally uses AI too, since that's exactly what it's good at: collecting and interpreting targeted information from huge databases – is a frighteningly accurate picture of

who you are, what interests you, what secretly interests you, and what you'll do in the coming days, weeks and years.

In a sense, Facebook and Instagram know you better than the people around you, or than you know yourself, since they follow your real actions and habits, not the image you project or the – naturally forgiving – view you have of yourself. They know how often you switch interests, how far you can and want to dive into certain topics, and what you think about the world.

About me, for example, they evidently knew that sooner or later a dog would come into my life.

Because they predict my life not just from my own decisions and habits, but from those of the people around me. They know who I live with, what's on their mind, and what of it „rubs off" on me, since they also know we talk every day. So I didn't even need to search for dog ownership myself; it was enough that my family did. But the ads could also have appeared by coincidence – the human lizard brain, conditioned to find patterns and running on ancient instincts, cries conspiracy even then – as Telex's video on the subject reminds us.

What about messages?

„OK, maybe my phone isn't listening, but it's definitely reading my messages" – many say in response to the arguments above. A fair assumption: Messenger and Instagram both belong to Facebook, surely they all collect data from each other, so why would the messaging app be an exception? The fact is, though, that in principle they don't – and may not – read your private messages to bombard you with ads, at least in theory. Instagram's head, Adam Mosseri said in a CBS programme a few years ago:

We don't look at messages, we don't listen through the microphone – that would be hugely problematic for many reasons. But I suppose no one believes me anyway.

What's more, social networks do monitor your private conversations – just for a different purpose. Facebook and Instagram openly state that every message passes through a machine filter that automatically screens dangerous, illegal (inciting) words, phrases and images, such as those linked to child pornography or human trafficking. In clear-cut cases, real people check too. But they insist they don't target ads based on private conversations.

What can I do?

As the saying goes: the devil's greatest trick is convincing us he doesn't exist. And the tech companies' trick is convincing us this system is fine, there's nothing wrong with it, nothing to see here – and anyway, it's free, so what's the problem?

  1. 99 percent of users don't mind: they're used to the flood of suspiciously well-targeted ads that seem to be in sync with what's happening in their lives anyway. The remaining one percent have two options: either start systematically withholding their data from social networks – so time- and energy-consuming that very few try, and even fewer keep it up. It's not a one-off job but requires constant attention. First you have to go through every setting in every app – and there are plenty of them – so they really learn and store nothing about you, and they may change their terms weekly, which can reset the settings to default......... So you may have to spend several days a week adjusting them. Of course, „nothing" doesn't exist: they'll track your content consumption habits either way. This is where VPNs come in, which for a few dollars a month stop anything reaching companies in a way they can link to you: complicated for laypeople, but effective – and of course social networks and other online services penalise it however they can.
  2. The other method is to check out of the internet: delete yourself from everywhere, ritually (and of course eco-consciously) get rid of your smartphone, and if sitting at a computer is unavoidable, email, browse and chat strictly in incognito mode. We won't tell you what to do, but let's just say we understand those for whom the latter seems a better idea every day.
AIsettingsbig datafacebookgmailgoogleeavesdroppingadvertisingfreeinstagrammessengermetaAIexpertphonetik-tok

More IT news and tips on the blog

More articles

See all articles →